Youth Baseball Gloves

The most common mistake is buying too big so it lasts two seasons. A glove a child can't close is a glove that drops balls all year.

How we make money: some links here earn us a commission if you buy. It costs you nothing and it does not change what we recommend — the rankings come from independent testing and owner reports, and we say plainly when a popular product has a problem. We have never been paid to include or rank anything.

1

Rawlings Gamer ContoUR

about $150

Strong verified-buyer consensus on fit and break-in

Built on a smaller hand opening and shorter finger stalls, which is the actual problem with most youth gloves — kids can't close them. Reviewers repeatedly note it breaks in far faster than a standard pattern, so it's usable in weeks rather than a season.

Best for:
9–13 year olds with genuinely small hands who need a real leather glove they can close.
Skip it if:
Your child has large hands — a standard adult pattern will fit and last longer.

Good

  • Youth-specific hand opening, not a shrunk adult glove
  • Breaks in quickly
  • Real leather at a sane price

Less good

  • Outgrown faster than a full-size glove
  • Not a lifetime glove
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: JustBallGloves verified-buyer reviews · BaseballMonkey sizing guides

2

Wilson A2000 (Pedroia Fit)

about $300

Consistently named the small-hands pick by owners

The A2000 in a narrower pattern built for small hands. It's expensive and stiff, and it will outlast several cheaper gloves — owners consistently report it carrying a player from 10U through high school. Buy it once, break it in properly, expect a season of work.

Best for:
A committed player with smaller hands who'll use it for years.
Skip it if:
Your child is 8 and may quit next spring. This is a lot of glove.

Good

  • Lasts multiple seasons
  • Narrow pattern genuinely fits small hands
  • Holds shape once broken in

Less good

  • $300
  • Long, real break-in period
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: r/Homeplate and r/BaseballGloves owner reports

3

Rawlings R9 Series

about $110

The default recommendation for a reason: real leather, holds its shape, priced where losing it isn't a disaster. Stiffer out of the box than the ContoUR, so budget a few weeks of catch.

Best for:
Most players. The sensible middle of the market.

Good

  • Durable leather at a mid price
  • Widely stocked in every size
  • Holds shape well

Less good

  • Stiff out of the box
  • Standard pattern — hard for very small hands to close
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: r/Homeplate and r/BaseballGloves owner reports · BaseballMonkey sizing guides

Other gear

🏏 Bats🥇 First base🪤 Catcher✋ Batting gloves⚙️ Machines🥅 Cages🎯 Training