Catcher's Mitts

A catcher's mitt has to be stiff enough to protect the hand and broken in enough to close. Youth patterns run 31–32.5 inches; a full-size 34-inch mitt is unusable for a ten-year-old.

How we make money: some links here earn us a commission if you buy. It costs you nothing and it does not change what we recommend — the rankings come from independent testing and owner reports, and we say plainly when a popular product has a problem. We have never been paid to include or rank anything.

1

All-Star Youth Pro Series (CM1000/1011)

about $110

Most-recommended youth catching mitt across owner threads

All-Star is the catching brand, and their youth series is the most-recommended youth mitt in every forum thread we read. Stiff enough to protect the hand, with a pocket that closes once broken in. Catching is the one position where cheap gear genuinely costs you.

Best for:
Any youth player catching regularly, roughly 9–13.
Skip it if:
Your child catches one inning a week — borrow the team mitt.

Good

  • Youth-scaled 31–32 inch patterns
  • Genuine hand protection
  • The brand catchers actually use

Less good

  • Needs real break-in
  • More than a general-purpose glove
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: r/Homeplate and r/BaseballGloves owner reports

2

Rawlings Renegade Catcher's Mitt

about $80

The starter mitt. Softer and cheaper than the All-Star, which means faster to use and faster to wear out. Right for a first season behind the plate before you know whether it sticks.

Best for:
A first-year catcher, or a team mitt.

Good

  • Usable almost immediately
  • Low cost for a trial season

Less good

  • Less protection than a pro-series mitt
  • Pocket softens quickly with volume
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: r/Homeplate and r/BaseballGloves owner reports · BaseballMonkey sizing guides

3

Akadema Youth Prodigy

about $120

A stiff mitt with a well-shaped pocket built specifically around a youth hand, and frequently available discounted. Less mainstream than All-Star, which is why it's often better value.

Best for:
A committed youth catcher whose parents shop on value.

Good

  • Stiff with a good pocket shape
  • Genuinely youth-sized
  • Often discounted

Less good

  • Harder to find in stores to try on
  • Less brand recognition
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: r/Homeplate and r/BaseballGloves owner reports

Other gear

🏏 Bats🧤 Gloves🥇 First base✋ Batting gloves⚙️ Machines🥅 Cages🎯 Training