First Base Mitts

First base mitts are longer, have no individual fingers and a shallower pocket built for scooping. Most youth players share a team mitt; buy one only if your child plays there regularly.

How we make money: some links here earn us a commission if you buy. It costs you nothing and it does not change what we recommend — the rankings come from independent testing and owner reports, and we say plainly when a popular product has a problem. We have never been paid to include or rank anything.

1

Rawlings Renegade First Base Mitt

about $80

The common budget recommendation from parents on forums

The answer to 'my kid plays some first base and I don't want to spend much'. Soft enough to use immediately, correct scooping shape, and cheap enough that a season of occasional use is fine value.

Best for:
A youth player who covers first sometimes rather than every game.

Good

  • Game-ready with minimal break-in
  • Low price for an occasional-use position
  • Correct first-base pattern

Less good

  • Won't last a dedicated first baseman multiple seasons
  • Basic leather
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: r/Homeplate and r/BaseballGloves owner reports

2

Mizuno Prospect First Base Mitt

about $100

A youth-scaled first base mitt from a brand that takes youth patterns seriously. Sized 11.5–12 inches rather than the adult 12.5–13, which matters — a full-size mitt is unusable for a 10-year-old.

Best for:
A regular youth first baseman aged roughly 9–13.

Good

  • Genuinely youth-sized, not a shrunk adult mitt
  • Good pocket depth for scooping

Less good

  • Narrower availability than Rawlings
  • Mid price for a single-position glove
Check price at AmazonCheck price at Dick'sCheck price at JustBats

Assessed from: BaseballMonkey sizing guides

Other gear

🏏 Bats🧤 Gloves🪤 Catcher✋ Batting gloves⚙️ Machines🥅 Cages🎯 Training